12-inch deep dish · approx. 2–2.5 inches
Butterscotch Cinnamon Apple Pie
Cinnamon apples and homemade butterscotch tucked into an all-butter crust.
Fresh apples and homemade butterscotch, all handmade from scratch.
Allergens listed: Wheat, milk
· ❧ ·
Oh, Hey! We Baked You a Pie.
Hey, Fatera! Bakery
The Thanksgiving Pie Collection
Handcrafted gourmet pies made from scratch with buttery homemade crusts, seasonal ingredients, and a little extra love.
PREORDER YOUR THANKSGIVING PIES →Small-batch baking in McKinney, Texas
PREORDERS OPEN NOW
ORDER WINDOW
NOW–NOV 19
Preorders are open now. Closes at 11:59 PM CST Nov 19, or earlier if sold out.
PICKUP
Nov 24–25
McKinney, Texas. Exact pickup details shared with confirmed customers.
SMALL-BATCH LIMITS
25 pies total · Maximum 4 pies per order · Pickup-slot capacity is checked manually.
THE THANKSGIVING PIE COLLECTION
Five pies, made for gathering.
Find your Thanksgiving favorite. Every pie is made to order in a limited seasonal batch.
12-inch standard depth
Pumpkin Crumble Pie
Spiced pumpkin custard finished with a buttery brown sugar crumble.
Fresh-roasted pumpkin filling, with every part handmade from scratch and finished with a buttery brown sugar crumble.
Allergens listed: Wheat, milk, eggs
12-inch standard depth
Southern Sweet Potato Pie
Homemade sweet potato custard, vanilla, and warm spices.
Handmade from scratch with vanilla and warm spices.
Allergens listed: Wheat, milk, eggs
12-inch standard depth
Buttermilk Cherry Almond Pie
Tangy buttermilk custard, cherries, almond flavor, and toasted almonds.
Handmade from scratch with cherries, almond flavor, and toasted almonds.
Allergens listed: Wheat, milk, eggs, tree nuts (almonds)
12-inch deep dish · approx. 2–2.5 inches
Cranberry Apple Crumble Pie
Apples, tart cranberries, cinnamon, and a buttery crumble topping.
Fresh apples and cranberries, all handmade from scratch.
Allergens listed: Wheat, milk
Pie photos are illustrative serving suggestions, not guaranteed depictions of the finished pies. Ingredient and allergen details are preliminary and must be verified against final tested recipes before orders open. Please keep pies refrigerated after pickup.
HOW PREORDERING WORKS
A little holiday planning, made simple.
Send us your pie selection and preferred pickup day. We’ll reply to confirm availability, time, and the pickup address near McKinney, Prosper, and Frisco.
Order limits
25 pies total across all flavors. Up to 4 pies per order and per pickup slot. Availability is confirmed manually.
Payment
Pay by Zelle to 580-917-9111 after we confirm your request. Payments and balances are tracked manually.
PICKUP IN MCKINNEY, TEXAS
Ready for your holiday table.
Choose November 24 or 25 when you send your request. We’ll confirm the exact pickup time and location privately with confirmed customers.
REQUEST YOUR PIESRequests are not confirmed reservations until we reply. Inventory, pickup availability, payment, and waitlist requests are handled manually.